It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
ISC: snip
Another one recommend me buying a cheap guitar and a decent USB link, and if I like it upgrade the guitar later:
http://www.thomann.de/gb/harley_benton_fv430bk.htm
http://www.thomann.de/gb/line6_pod_studio_ux2.htm

What do you think about it? What's best to start from absolute zero?

Also, in an unrelated note, my wife is buying a violin. No, she has no idea of playing violin also. Yes, we're weirdos.
I say get the cheap V bundle with the amp, as then you can just plug in and play, and not have to bother getting the PC link set up and then you are your wife can jam :D.

In my experience a year jamming with some fun people does more to improve your playing than 10 years playing on your own, so find someone to jam with.
avatar
ISC:
avatar
dizcology: I assume you have somehow played guitar before? It is somewhat risky to just dive head in without at least some idea about what you are getting into.

Anyhow, I would suggest getting a better guitar than a cheap one, but that's just me. And by the way, as far as I understand it, the V-shaped guitars look cool, but probably do not work so well acoustically by itself. So this means you definitely need to invest on nice effects (e.g. the all-in-one line6 boxes you listed - I personally prefer individual effects).

An perhaps more importantly, what's going to be your amplifier+speaker setup? Even with a great guitar and effects, you'll need proper amps to actually produce the sound.
Composite guitars come in all sorts of shapes, and you won't get much of a sound difference between them on a basic level. As with any electric non-acoustic guitar, you will have little to no real sound without amplification. And today, you can get all sorts of different sounds and effects to get the basic sounds you want with a stand alone amp, or amp modeler (pod studio I've used, as well as other effects processors, though I'm mainly a singer).

For a beginner, this is what I recommend- find a cheap guitar that is decent quality. That means you will spend $200+ to get one that doesn't have bad wiring, a neck with a truss rod to prevent the neck from warping, or other stuff with crap guitars. A couple things to keep in mind: do not get a floating bridge (aka tremelo...it'll take a beginner 3 hours to tune it even remotely close to being in tune), get one with passive pickups (active sound better but require batteries and will generally be $200 more), composite guitars are significantly lighter but don't have as warm/full of sound as regular wood one(composite is better for hard rock/metal, but crappy for blues, rock, jazz), flatter necks= faster speed, but go with comfort for your hands, go to a store and play around on one before buying.

When it comes to the rest of what you want, buy according to your needs. If you want to play through a speaker, get an amp. Buy a cheap practice amp with a couple effects so you know if you like playing or not. Metal/ hard rock needs some distortion. If you want to record, with headphones, or have very limited space (like an apartment) get something like a pod. It has built in amp modeling (makes it sound like it's coming through an amp even though it is not). Or make sure your amp has a headphone output.

If you want to bypass all that and get an acoustic-electric guitar, I will look up the Yamaha model I have, as it is about $299, has a thinner body which is easier for new players, sounds like a $600 guitar, and I love it. The next step up is around $700 for better sound.

Once you play, you will see if you love it or not. Dont spend a lot until you KNOW you like it.

I have performed, recorded with a Grammy winning producer who wanted to sign me and my (former) band to his label, and been sought out by bands with radio play and major record company contracts. I'm a singer, not primarily a guitarist, but I''ve been around it enough that I'll gladly answer any questions you have accurately. Feel free to send me a PM if youwant.

And if any of this doesn't make sense, ask. I'm writing this from my phone and it keeps screwing up.

Also, bundle guitar + amp deals are hit and miss. Check out online reviews of them. I can't check out your links right now. Oh, and never ever buy "first act" brand, unless it is for an 8 year old. They are worse than all others, sold at Walmart, and you can get better stuff for the same price.

... And you aren't weird. I have been a performing cello and trombonist prior to a metal/hard rock/acoustic singer, guitarist, and bass player. Music is amazing :)
Post edited June 10, 2013 by Braussie
Thanks everybody (and specially to Braussie for his precise advices).

I gave it a lot of thinking, and I'm going with the middle way: Buying the cheap guitar and replace all the wiring. The Harley Benton has a very decent body and neck but the pickups and wiring in general are shit, so a pair of decent pickups and two 500K pot. for volume and a push/pull one for tone gives a decent guitar for 200€. It looks like a real Flying V, it should sound pretty good (basswood body, maple neck) and it will be fun to play with its internals. (I swear that I had no idea of whatever I said above but Internet is EVIL! First you search for reviews of the guitar, then in a review someone comments on changing the pickups, then potis, then push/pull... TOO MUCH INFORMATION!)

I searched for any V shaped guitar for about the same budget (including ports), but it was impossible to find one.

And then, I'll try to play it... somehow.

Will upload some pics of the process of building the Franken-V :P
avatar
ISC: Snip
Good luck :-) What about an amp?
avatar
ISC: Snip
avatar
makr3la: Good luck :-) What about an amp?
Yamaha THR-10
Basically a recording studio about the size of a shoe box. Just got one for Christmas. You can't play gigs with it but that's not the point, this is a noob here.
avatar
makr3la: Good luck :-) What about an amp?
I'm going to try with an USB link. A Line 6 Pod Studio GX: a lot of effects for learning and experimenting.
avatar
makr3la: Good luck :-) What about an amp?
avatar
ISC: I'm going to try with an USB link. A Line 6 Pod Studio GX: a lot of effects for learning and experimenting.
Let us know how you doing after a while! Have fun and HNGD! :-)
You think you're weirdos? As far as I'm concerned, you guys are friggin' royalty!

In terms of gear, spend only as much as you are willing and it will be fine. I have several guitars and one of my favourites is a $100 Strat copy that picked up in a 2nd hand store. I also have an expensive one that I love as well. My first guitar I absolutely hated. My friend still plays his 1st guitar. What's the moral of the story? Set a price you are happy with and dive in!!!

Re: violin. It's a beautiful instrument, but damn, those first few months will sound like swinging a cat by its tail :P Don't give up!
avatar
makr3la: Good luck :-) What about an amp?
avatar
ISC: I'm going to try with an USB link. A Line 6 Pod Studio GX: a lot of effects for learning and experimenting.
I know you had already decided on Line 6, but just for fun, you might consider Pandora Box as well. (Don't really know if it does all the things the Line 6 GX does, though!)
Post edited June 13, 2013 by dizcology
avatar
ISC: Thanks everybody (and specially to Braussie for his precise advices).

I gave it a lot of thinking, and I'm going with the middle way: Buying the cheap guitar and replace all the wiring. The Harley Benton has a very decent body and neck but the pickups and wiring in general are shit, so a pair of decent pickups and two 500K pot. for volume and a push/pull one for tone gives a decent guitar for 200€. It looks like a real Flying V, it should sound pretty good (basswood body, maple neck) and it will be fun to play with its internals. (I swear that I had no idea of whatever I said above but Internet is EVIL! First you search for reviews of the guitar, then in a review someone comments on changing the pickups, then potis, then push/pull... TOO MUCH INFORMATION!)

I searched for any V shaped guitar for about the same budget (including ports), but it was impossible to find one.

And then, I'll try to play it... somehow.

Will upload some pics of the process of building the Franken-V :P
Also about cheap guitars keep in mind that there is a possibility they come with really crappy tuning hardware that would make them hard to stay in tune and a nut that could make one of your strings buzz. It's rarely the case but still it happens because they are mass produced and aren't as well checked as the other fancy guitars. It's a bit of a gamble if you're not in the store trying it out before buying.
Post edited June 13, 2013 by morciu
avatar
ISC: I'm going to try with an USB link. A Line 6 Pod Studio GX: a lot of effects for learning and experimenting.
avatar
dizcology: I know you had already decided on Line 6, but just for fun, you might consider Pandora Box as well. (Don't really know if it does all the things the Line 6 GX does, though!)
Oh, it does, and more!

Very interesting gadget, but too expensive for what I want right now. The GX is only a USB link and being over 80€ an expensive one, but it guarantees very low latency even in Win7 (and has a nifty software with a lot of amps and effects). For the moment I'm going to play (or better: try playing) only in home so I don't think I need a portable pod.