timppu: So how about Scotland's independence, yay or nayay? Are you for the new referendum?
wpegg: Against! They had the referendum, the terms were all agreed there and then - not again for another generation. Referendums should be final regardless of whether you like the result or not, simply because otherwise the losing side will just keep on calling for a rematch, and given the disruption these 2 we've had have caused, that would just become ridiculous very soon.
It depends on the legal framework. GB had article 50 as a guaranteed right. So they could even have asked the people 10 times in different years, then take the average and trigger the article or not. They could ask anytime again. Indeed, in Switzerland they often vote multiple times on the same stuff when time goes by, because the people decide themselves if they want to have a referendum about anything.
For Scotland they don't have a guaranteed right to be independent. They live on the goodwill of Westminster. It's not for us to decide whether they'll get it.
What if in polls there would be a majority for independence now in Scotland? The guy who decides that they can vote then effectively would decide if they could go. So if you afraid of them going, better not giving them the chance to vote on it.