Posted December 12, 2019

Lifthrasil
Bring the GOG-Downloader back!
Registered: Apr 2011
From Germany

JoeSapphire
Consultant Liar
Registered: Jun 2011
From United Kingdom

PookaMustard
モニカ。モニカだけ。
Registered: Jun 2013
From Other

JoeSapphire
Consultant Liar
Registered: Jun 2011
From United Kingdom

JoeSapphire
Consultant Liar
Registered: Jun 2011
From United Kingdom
Posted December 12, 2019
If the game's not over I think it's worth not discounting dedo-as-lone-scum scenario.
I think I was wrong when I logicked its impossibility - I thought that dedo couldn't be lone scum because his block was confirmed by RW, but a lone mafia roleblocker isn't stretching the *
dedoporno: Of course it does. For the sake of discussion let's assume that the SK and the lone Kitsune are exactly the same, but one is a Serial Killer while the other is Mafia whatever. Other than that, power-wise, they are exactly the same thing. Everyone knows the Kitsune exist, no one knows the Serial Killer exists until that it becomes obvious. Don't you think the hidden guy has a bit of an edge over his counterpart, regardless how small or short-lived it might be? The significance of this only just occurred to me... I totally failed to see Dedo's point here, because it didn't occur to me that he was look at it from the scum's perspective... (something it would have been nice if one of you had noticed but ah well)
But if I saw it from town's perspective, dedo saw it from scum's perspective. - Doesn't mean dedo's not just got more imagination than I do, but it's worth baring in mind.
* I wrote this post in a funny order so I'm just skipping to the end now - a lone mafia roleblocker doesn't make any sense does it? Hummm... maybe with a serial killer a protective role for the mafia makes sense? Except the serial killer can't be blocked so no it doesn't.
AH WELL Probably the game's over anyway and I've just embarrassed myself one final time.
Any chance any of you forgot to unvote?..
I think I was wrong when I logicked its impossibility - I thought that dedo couldn't be lone scum because his block was confirmed by RW, but a lone mafia roleblocker isn't stretching the *

But if I saw it from town's perspective, dedo saw it from scum's perspective. - Doesn't mean dedo's not just got more imagination than I do, but it's worth baring in mind.
* I wrote this post in a funny order so I'm just skipping to the end now - a lone mafia roleblocker doesn't make any sense does it? Hummm... maybe with a serial killer a protective role for the mafia makes sense? Except the serial killer can't be blocked so no it doesn't.
AH WELL Probably the game's over anyway and I've just embarrassed myself one final time.
Any chance any of you forgot to unvote?..

Lifthrasil
Bring the GOG-Downloader back!
Registered: Apr 2011
From Germany
Posted December 12, 2019

But now I wonder:
The 'if' strongly implies that you aren't lone scum, at least. The game would be over then. But are you preparing the ground for a scumbuddy, giving him an angle to go after dedo tomorrow? Or are you actually Town? The way you stick to your 'you've made a mistake', even though the hammer is already done, makes me think that maybe you are, after all. Or are you just toying with us for fun and giggles?
...well, we will see when trent appears here.

JoeSapphire
Consultant Liar
Registered: Jun 2011
From United Kingdom

Lifthrasil
Bring the GOG-Downloader back!
Registered: Apr 2011
From Germany

trentonlf
Easily amused
Registered: Apr 2014
From United States
Posted December 12, 2019
A lynch has occurred, give me about 30 minutes.

trentonlf
Easily amused
Registered: Apr 2014
From United States

JoeSapphire
Consultant Liar
Registered: Jun 2011
From United Kingdom
Posted December 12, 2019
Gather round to praise me now.

PookaMustard
モニカ。モニカだけ。
Registered: Jun 2013
From Other
Posted December 12, 2019
vote Lifthrasil

PookaMustard
モニカ。モニカだけ。
Registered: Jun 2013
From Other
Posted December 12, 2019
I knew we were dealing with an all star scumteam, and of course it had to include Lift. Still, congrats for you two!
I'm kinda scattered (when am I not scattered?) so sparse comments here and there. I like how the two of you agreed on me being vanilla D1...but hot damn, I almost got SCUM lynched D1, without a "me Baka, Watcher of Kalunga" situation happening...the whole point of my non-claim was indeed to invoke a Schrodinger's Cat scenario, where either I am a power role or I am not, and get killed because of the WIFOM factor. Ultimately it failed.
Also, Agent and I were so close to figuring out the other actual scum, only to be dissuaded by the mechanics (I genuinely thought dedo's jail was a simple roleblock).
I'm kinda scattered (when am I not scattered?) so sparse comments here and there. I like how the two of you agreed on me being vanilla D1...but hot damn, I almost got SCUM lynched D1, without a "me Baka, Watcher of Kalunga" situation happening...the whole point of my non-claim was indeed to invoke a Schrodinger's Cat scenario, where either I am a power role or I am not, and get killed because of the WIFOM factor. Ultimately it failed.
Also, Agent and I were so close to figuring out the other actual scum, only to be dissuaded by the mechanics (I genuinely thought dedo's jail was a simple roleblock).
Post edited December 12, 2019 by PookaMustard

Lifthrasil
Bring the GOG-Downloader back!
Registered: Apr 2011
From Germany

blotunga
GrumpyOldGamers.CyringOutMiserably
Registered: Apr 2012
From Other
Posted December 12, 2019
Ok, so next time we lynch the prisoner if there was no NK.
Also after Pooka's quick hammer I really thought he might be scum. Lift pounding on the one scum theory should've been a warning flag aswell.
Also after Pooka's quick hammer I really thought he might be scum. Lift pounding on the one scum theory should've been a warning flag aswell.
Post edited December 12, 2019 by blotunga