Posted August 17, 2019
Imagine you were met with something that you had actually seen before a long time ago but somehow didn't remember. Let's say it's movie. So you went over the whole movie and recalled some of the scenes from the film that made you say,"Ahh, I remember that!" That way, it was clear that your memories had just returned back to you.
Now, let us think of that same scenario but with a different outcome. What if I said that the scenes which I had mentioned in the previous paragraph did not appear and instead replaced with different ones. Would your mind just accept those new information as what they are (like,"Oh, maybe those scenes did happen in the movie) or would it disturb your mind so much with an uneasy feeling that something is missing? The thing is, I doubt we would ever encounter the latter as it's just illogical for something such as a movie for example, to change if it were still the original version.
The reason as to why I asked the question is because I've been encountered with this situation a few times in my life such as passing by a street that I haven't seen for so long, and more. Obviously, I know that things do change, but sometimes whenever I see things that do click with my memories (meaning the things remain the same or if we were to relate it back to the street that I had just mentioned, the streets did not change), a thought enters my mind and ask me whether I would've felt differently if those things had changed.
I really do hope you guys have ever felt this sort of skepticism before as it would really help you familiarize yourself with the question that I'm asking or even understand it. Thank you.
Now, let us think of that same scenario but with a different outcome. What if I said that the scenes which I had mentioned in the previous paragraph did not appear and instead replaced with different ones. Would your mind just accept those new information as what they are (like,"Oh, maybe those scenes did happen in the movie) or would it disturb your mind so much with an uneasy feeling that something is missing? The thing is, I doubt we would ever encounter the latter as it's just illogical for something such as a movie for example, to change if it were still the original version.
The reason as to why I asked the question is because I've been encountered with this situation a few times in my life such as passing by a street that I haven't seen for so long, and more. Obviously, I know that things do change, but sometimes whenever I see things that do click with my memories (meaning the things remain the same or if we were to relate it back to the street that I had just mentioned, the streets did not change), a thought enters my mind and ask me whether I would've felt differently if those things had changed.
I really do hope you guys have ever felt this sort of skepticism before as it would really help you familiarize yourself with the question that I'm asking or even understand it. Thank you.
Post edited August 17, 2019 by Vingry