1. Yellow
2. Horse
3. Toothbrush
4. Spoon
5. Pillow
6. Foot
7. Zeno of Citium
8. 4
9. Hail
10. Rectangle
11. Sapphire
12. Tyrian 2000
13. Imoen
14. Rayman Forever
15. Riven
16. Cossacks Anthology
17. Return to Krondor
18. Apache Longbow
19. Wing Commander Privateer
20. Slipstream 5000

Zangtesu still has the lead with 18 out of 20 (post 37)
leaguehq also has 18 out of 20 in post 42
adambiser has 18 out of 20 in post 46

1 - Yellow
2. - Monkey
3 – Toothbrush
4 – Spoon
5 – Pillow
6 – Foot
7 – Zeno of Citium
8 - 4
9. Hail
10 - Rectangle
11 - Sapphire
12. Tyrian 2000
13 - Imoen
14 – Rayman Forever
15 - Riven
16 - Cossacks Anthology
17 - Return to Krondor
18- Apache Longbow
19 - Wing Commander™ 3
20 - World Rally Fever: Born on the Road

Zangtesu still has the lead with 18 out of 20 (post 37)
leaguehq also has 18 out of 20 in post 42
adambiser has 18 out of 20 in post 46

1. Yellow
2. Cow
3. Toothbrush
4. Spoon
5. Pillow
6. Eye
7. Zeno of Citium
8. 4
9. Hail
10. Rectangle
11. Sapphire
12. Tyrian 2000
13. Imoen
14. Rayman Forever
15. Riven
16. Cossacks Anthology
17. Return to Krondor
18. Apache Longbow
19. Wing Commander Privateer
20. Slipstream 5000

Zangtesu still has the lead with 18 out of 20 (post 37)
leaguehq also has 18 out of 20 in post 42
adambiser has 18 out of 20 in post 46

As of this post, no one has #2 yet. I swear, it's a regular animal, nothing crazy.

1 - Yellow
2. - Hamster
3 – Toothbrush
4 – Spoon
5 – Pillow
6 – Foot
7 – Zeno of Citium
8 - 4
9. Hail
10 - Rectangle
11 - Sapphire
12. Tyrian 2000
13 - Imoen
14 – Rayman Forever
15 - Riven
16 - Cossacks Anthology
17 - Return to Krondor
18- Apache Longbow
19 - Wing Commander™ 1+2
20 - POD Gold

Zangtesu still has the lead with 18 out of 20 (post 37)
leaguehq also has 18 out of 20 in post 42
adambiser has 18 out of 20 in post 46

1. Yellow
2. Chicken
3. Toothbrush
4. Spoon
5. Pillow
6. Foot
7. Zeno of Citium
8. 4
9. Hail
10. Rectangle
11. Sapphire
12. Tyrian 2000
13. Imoen
14. Rayman Forever
15. Riven
16. Cossacks Anthology
17. Return to Krondor
18. Apache Longbow
19. Blake Stone: Aliens of Gold
20. Slipstream 5000

Zangtesu still has the lead with 18 out of 20 (post 37)
leaguehq also has 18 out of 20 in post 42
adambiser has 18 out of 20 in post 46

1. Yellow
2. Pig
3. Toothbrush
4. Spoon
5. Pillow
6. Foot
7. Zeno of Citium
8. 4
9. Hail
10. Rectangle
11. Sapphire
12. Tyrian 2000
13. Imoen
14. Rayman Forever
15. Riven
16. Cossacks Anthology
17. Return to Krondor
18. Apache Longbow
19. Wing Commander™ 3 Heart of the Tiger™
20. Slipstream 5000

1 - Yellow
2. - Chicken
3 – Toothbrush
4 – Spoon
5 – Pillow
6 – Foot
7 – Zeno of Citium
8 - 4
9. Hail
10 - Rectangle
11 - Sapphire
12. Tyrian 2000
13 - Imoen
14 – Rayman Forever
15 - Riven
16 - Cossacks Anthology
17 - Return to Krondor
18- Apache Longbow
19 - Wing Commander™ 1+2
20 - Moto Racer

Zangtesu still has the lead with 18 out of 20 (post 37)
leaguehq also has 18 out of 20 in post 42
adambiser has 18 out of 20 in post 46

No one has #2 right yet, so here's another hint: it has 5 letters or less in its name.

I'll add this clue to the original post, also.

1. Yellow
2. Bear
3. Toothbrush
4. Spoon
5. Pillow
6. Foot
7. Zeno of Citium
8. 4
9. Hail
10. Rectangle
11. Sapphire
12. Tyrian 2000
13. Imoen
14. Rayman Forever
15. Riven
16. Cossacks Anthology
17. Return to Krondor
18. Apache Longbow
19. Wing Commander™ 3 Heart of the Tiger™
20. Slipstream 5000

1 - Yellow
2. - Sheep
3 – Toothbrush
4 – Spoon
5 – Pillow
6 – Foot
7 – Zeno of Citium
8 - 4
9. Hail
10 - Rectangle
11 - Sapphire
12. Tyrian 2000
13 - Imoen
14 – Rayman Forever
15 - Riven
16 - Cossacks Anthology
17 - Return to Krondor
18- Apache Longbow
19 - Wing Commander™ 1+2
20 - Screamer