PCGameGuy: I beg to differ, I am currently on the Live site in another tab and it seems that the only thing stopping me from buying Alice 1 is a lack of 213 MS points. I clicked on Madness returns, clicked on American McGee's Alice, and it popped up with the confirmation page.
Unless it happens AFTER you pay for it, it seems that buying #1 for 800 points via the website is completely possible. I recall the pre-release advertising seemed to indicate you had to have the second one, and on my PC digital copy I have to access it via the second games launcher, but I did not attempt to purchase it separately on PC.
Has anyone actually tried to buy it via live and failed, or is this all speculation still?
Nobody's stopping you from buying it. They'll let you buy it. You just can't use it without the disc. It clearly says it's an add-on.
See how it has a controller icon with a + on it? That means it's an add-on that goes with something else. By contrast Duke Nukem 3D
, Has just a controller icon and says download full game.
It's been confirmed on other sites I've visited. You need the disc or else you're just giving away 800 points.