It is nearing the end of 2011 & the major releases are running dry & with that knowledge I really see no reason to wait to make this thread.

Its time to do Game of the Year polling!

Here is the format of the list

Game of the Year 2011-
Worst Game of the Year 2011-
Surprise of the Year 2011-
Letdown of the Year 2011-
Best Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year)-
Worst Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year)-

At the beginning of next year I will do a Tally & we will announce the GOG game of the Year Awards. You are free to change your list any time between your initial post & January 1st. Now get to polling!

Best game I played this year: Dragon Age
Worst game I played this year (or possibly, ever): Dragon Age 2

I only bought very few new games this year (might buy some more after my exams), but out of those my picks would be:

Game of the Year 2011 : The Witcher 2

Best Game Played This Year : Heroes of Might & Magic III
Worst Game Played This Year : Blood 2

I didn't buy any bad games or letdowns.

/edit: I don't really know what "Surprise of the Year" means.. If it means "didn't expect to be good, but actually was", then Might & Magic Heroes 6.

Wow... this got buried fast...

Minecraft would be in the running for best game of the year, but its been so popular as a beta that I think it will end up with many not voting simply because they don't see it as a 2011 game. Skyrim will most likely fit into this years top game on the PC at least.


Game of the Year 2011- Minecraft!!

Worst Game of the Year 2011-

Surprise of the Year 2011- Bastion

Letdown of the Year 2011- Sword of the Stars 2 - a let down only in how terribly unfinished and buggy the current code is; provided the company keeps working I fully expect (and hope) this to be a top 2012 title (at least for the 4*genre players)

Best Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year)- Based on hours its either Minecraft or Sword of the Stars

Worst Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year)- er no idea ;)

Game of the Year 2011 - Skyrim!
Worst Game of the Year 2011 - I could list a ton of Wii/Kinect games.. but that's obvious... i'm gonna go with "War in the North"
Surprise of the Year 2011 - Shadows of the Damned
Letdown of the Year 2011 - Battlefield 3
Best Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year) - Skyrim!
Worst Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year) - No More Heroes

Game of the Year 2011- Shogun 2 Total war
Worst Game of the Year 2011-
Surprise of the Year 2011- Skyrim (it didn't suck? huh?)
Letdown of the Year 2011- Airline Tycoon 2
Best Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year)- Shogun 2 TW
Worst Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year)-

I don't have a complete list of the games I played so far this year... still waiting for lukaszthegreat to provide a complete spreadsheet. ;)

With that in mind, I'll wait with filling out my list (odds are I'll leave the "worst game" categories blank as well - I adore most of my games!).

Still, as a teaser I'll let you know SpaceChem was the surprise hit of the year for me. Incredibly difficult, but brilliant execution. Most people won't have the patience to beat it - I've still got a world and a half left, although that's mostly because my computer died before I could get to them...

i said that on RPS and I say it here:

Terraria

Had 60 hours of fun with it and will have more for sure but it also provided us with TB and Jessie Playing Terraria which is great and hilarious series. sorry. don't count on it. Spreadsheet didn't work. way too much time consuming and now it is a bit too late.

will do better in 2012 and it will be the old style (only on gog. will create new account so we will have space)

Game of the Year 2011- Dark Souls.

Such refreshing gameplay. Too many other rpgs released these days feel like they've been boiled down to twenty minutes of button mashing in between cutscenes - repeated over the course of the game.

Game of the year- The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky (Runner Up: Ghost Trick)
Worst Game of the year- Crysis 2 (Runner up: Bastion)
Surprise of the Year- Gears of War 3
Letdown of the Year- Bastion
Best Game Played this Year- Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors
Worst Game Played this Year- Crysis 2

Keep in mind that I haven't really played any bad games this year, so choosing the worst game of the year was kind of hard.

Game of the Year 2011- The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Best Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year)- Skyrim
Worst Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year)- Dragon Age 2

Game of the Year 2011 - Dark Souls
Worst Game of the Year 2011 - Dungeon Siege 3
Surprise of the Year 2011 - Deus Ex - Human Revolution
Letdown of the Year 2011 - L.A. Noire
Best Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year) - Demon's Souls
Worst Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year) - Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games.

Game of the Year 2011- (no vote)
Worst Game of the Year 2011- (no vote)
Surprise of the Year 2011- (no vote)
Letdown of the Year 2011- Airline Tycoon 2
Best Game Played This Year - Rome: TW Gold
Worst Game Played This Year - Airline Tycoon 2

Game of the Year 2011 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Worst Game of the Year 2011 - [later]
Surprise of the Year 2011 - Gemini Rue
Letdown of the Year 2011 - FEAR 3
Best Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year) - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Worst Game Played This Year (not limited to games released this year) - [later]