FlintlockJazz: This is ironic, as lately I was seriously considering getting a PS2 just to try these games. Unfortunately it looks like they are only going to be coming out for the PS3, which I have no intention of buying, so may still have to stick to the 'buy PS2' approach. Ah well, they are usually better in the original form anyway!
bansama: Of course, if you then find you like them, you'll have to get a PS3 to play the next one. So you may as well just get the PS3 if you think there's the slightest possibility that you're going to want to follow the series after playing the first two.
FlintlockJazz: This is ironic, as lately I was seriously considering getting a PS2 just to try these games. Unfortunately it looks like they are only going to be coming out for the PS3, which I have no intention of buying, so may still have to stick to the 'buy PS2' approach. Ah well, they are usually better in the original form anyway!
Npl: SotC had horrible slowdowns, there is hope that the port will fix this. It really made a couple fights frustrating.
SO from the perspective of getting the better version of these 2 games then you should atleast wait for a review of the final version I can understand that PS2 is a more appealing Console for the amount of Genres and excellent games - something no other console is close, and from the looks of it wont coming close ever (thanks to the mainstream FPS crap thats the whole focus now).
Gonna buy the collection for SotC, couldnt stand Ico. And hopefully some good sales will motivate other publishers to follow suit with their own games, there are tons of gems on PS2 which would deserve it.
Thanks for the advice, I'll see how these HD versions turn out then before buying anything, though I'm not sure whether I'd still get a PS3, while I was considering getting either a 360 or PS3 I'm primarily a PC gamer and most of the games I would play them on are also on PC, which is my prefered platform, so it's been rather awkward for me to justify it to myself. ;)
PS2 has got the big catalog of games, though to be honest the only two games I can name at the moment that are only available on it that I would play is ironically Ico and SotC. :D I'm sure that there is something that will pop up that will help me make up my mind though, thanks again for the advice..