Gazoinks: How's Superbrothers? Another one I've heard mixed stuff about.
I love it :)
but I also love The Path, Dear Esther and some other rather obscure games... I really like the atmosphere, absolutely adore the
soundtrack (which I bought before the game and listen to almost every day :o), and even though it's rather slow game and isn't even that long, about 5-6 hours I'd say, for me it was money very well spent...
(also, I've bought the game just because of the soundtrack and some screenshots, I didn't even know what genre it was until I've started playing... perfect :D
EDIT: added a link to my favourite track from it