Lol, posting at the same time messed that up! Here's an update to take account of both our votes:

1. Street Fighter 22
2. The King of Fighters 2
3. Virtua Fighter 2
4. Tekken 5
5. Soul Edge/Calibur 13
6. Mortal Kombat 17
7. Killer Instinct 7
8. Capcom Vs 2
9. Guilty Gear 9
10. Dead or Alive 0
11. One Must Fall 4
12. Darkstalkers 4
13. Pocket Fighter 4
14. Garou: Mark of the Wolves 3
15. IK+ 2
16. Fatal Fury 0
17. Body Blows 0
18. Last Blade/Samurai Showdown 2
19. Sango Fighter 5
20. Yie Ar Kung Fu 1
21. Super Smash Bros 3
22. Powerstone 1
23. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure 2

I'm saddened by the lack of people that have either played powerstone or liked it :(

I liked Powerstone and Kung Fu Chaos, but I liked other fighting games here more. :)

Dammit I shoulda remembered Def Jam: Fight for New York >.<

1. Street Fighter 20
2. The King of Fighters 2
3. Virtua Fighter 2
4. Tekken 5
5. Soul Edge/Calibur 13
6. Mortal Kombat 17
7. Killer Instinct 7
8. Capcom Vs 2
9. Guilty Gear 11
10. Dead or Alive 0
11. One Must Fall 4
12. Darkstalkers 4
13. Pocket Fighter 4
14. Garou: Mark of the Wolves 3
15. IK+ 2
16. Fatal Fury 0
17. Body Blows 0
18. Last Blade/Samurai Showdown 2
19. Sango Fighter 5
20. Yie Ar Kung Fu 1
21. Super Smash Bros 3
22. Powerstone 1
23. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure 2

-2 to Street Fighter
+2 to Guilty Gear

1. Street Fighter 22
2. The King of Fighters 2
3. Virtua Fighter 2
4. Tekken 5
5. Soul Edge/Calibur 13
6. Mortal Kombat 17
7. Killer Instinct 7
8. Capcom Vs 2
9. Guilty Gear 11
10. Dead or Alive 0
11. One Must Fall 5
12. Darkstalkers 4
13. Pocket Fighter 4
14. Garou: Mark of the Wolves 3
15. IK+ 2
16. Fatal Fury 1
17. Body Blows 0
18. Last Blade/Samurai Showdown 2
19. Sango Fighter 5
20. Yie Ar Kung Fu 1
21. Super Smash Bros 3
22. Powerstone 1
23. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure 2

SF +2
OMF +1
FF +1

1. Street Fighter 23
2. The King of Fighters 3
3. Virtua Fighter 2
4. Tekken 5
5. Soul Edge/Calibur 13
6. Mortal Kombat 18
7. Killer Instinct 7
8. Capcom Vs 2
9. Guilty Gear 12
10. Dead or Alive 0
11. One Must Fall 5
12. Darkstalkers 4
13. Pocket Fighter 4
14. Garou: Mark of the Wolves 3
15. IK+ 2
16. Fatal Fury 1
17. Body Blows 0
18. Last Blade/Samurai Showdown 2
19. Sango Fighter 5
20. Yie Ar Kung Fu 1
21. Super Smash Bros 3
22. Powerstone 1
23. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure 2

Hope I did it right...

Hmmm looks like the score's bollixed up now. From what I see, SF should be at 27 now.

Also, OMG I can't believe I forgot VF - VF4 Evolution is probably my most played fighting game (apart from SF) - so subtract 1 from SF and add 1 to VF... (Of course, feel free to ignore this if it completely fucks your head up Delixe)

:)

P.S. Fair enough about the LB / SS thing. Still reckon they should be separate but meh, minor quibble.

P.P.S. I'm intrigued by how many people are voting MK - is it just me or is it because the newest fighting game out is a MK game and it's been causing controversy again? *food for thought*

P.P.P.S. I think that the reason KoF is scoring so low is because the last one was an abomination and pretty much fucked up everyone about that series. Sad but true.

aah, never knew that, not a fan of the series myself. I just figured with the thousands of KOF chars you can download for mugen (and the amount of games there is) I just expected it to do better :)

1. Street Fighter 26
2. The King of Fighters 3
3. Virtua Fighter 2
4. Tekken 5
5. Soul Edge/Calibur 13
6. Mortal Kombat 18
7. Killer Instinct 7
8. Capcom Vs 2
9. Guilty Gear 12
10. Dead or Alive 0
11. One Must Fall 5
12. Darkstalkers 4
13. Pocket Fighter 4
14. Garou: Mark of the Wolves 3
15. IK+ 3
16. Fatal Fury 1
17. Body Blows 0
18. Last Blade/Samurai Showdown 2
19. Sango Fighter 5
20. Yie Ar Kung Fu 1
21. Super Smash Bros 3
22. Powerstone 1
23. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure 2

+3 Street Fighter, +1 IK+ !

Think you're right, I'm just continuing from post #51 in my list though.

If there was only one point in it I would re-calculate but at the moment I think we should stick with the current totals for simplicity. I will have to go over all the entries again to find the final top ten anyway and to put names in the hat. Well I say hat I mean Random.org of course :p

1. Street Fighter 26
2. The King of Fighters 3
3. Virtua Fighter 2
4. Tekken 5
5. Soul Edge/Calibur 13
6. Mortal Kombat 22
7. Killer Instinct 7
8. Capcom Vs 2
9. Guilty Gear 12
10. Dead or Alive 0
11. One Must Fall 5
12. Darkstalkers 4
13. Pocket Fighter 4
14. Garou: Mark of the Wolves 3
15. IK+ 3
16. Fatal Fury 1
17. Body Blows 0
18. Last Blade/Samurai Showdown 2
19. Sango Fighter 5
20. Yie Ar Kung Fu 1
21. Super Smash Bros 3
22. Powerstone 1
23. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure 2

+4 MK.

1. Street Fighter 28 (+2)
2. The King of Fighters 3
3. Virtua Fighter 2
4. Tekken 5
5. Soul Edge/Calibur 13
6. Mortal Kombat 24 (+2)
7. Killer Instinct 7
8. Capcom Vs 2
9. Guilty Gear 12
10. Dead or Alive 0
11. One Must Fall 5
12. Darkstalkers 4
13. Pocket Fighter 4
14. Garou: Mark of the Wolves 3
15. IK+ 3
16. Fatal Fury 1
17. Body Blows 0
18. Last Blade/Samurai Showdown 2
19. Sango Fighter 5
20. Yie Ar Kung Fu 1
21. Super Smash Bros 3
22. Powerstone 1
23. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure 2

1. Street Fighter 26
2. The King of Fighters 3
3. Virtua Fighter 2
4. Tekken 5
5. Soul Edge/Calibur 13
6. Mortal Kombat 22
7. Killer Instinct 7
8. Capcom Vs 2
9. Guilty Gear 12
10. Dead or Alive 0
11. One Must Fall 5
12. Darkstalkers 4
13. Pocket Fighter 4
14. Garou: Mark of the Wolves 3
15. IK+ 3
16. Fatal Fury 1
17. Body Blows 0
18. Last Blade/Samurai Showdown 2
19. Sango Fighter 5
20. Yie Ar Kung Fu 1
21. Super Smash Bros 3
22. Powerstone 1
23. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure 2
24. Way Of The Exploding Fist 4

Old School Rules - on the speccy anyway....;o)

1. Street Fighter 26
2. The King of Fighters 3
3. Virtua Fighter 2
4. Tekken 5
5. Soul Edge/Calibur 14
6. Mortal Kombat 22
7. Killer Instinct 7
8. Capcom Vs 2
9. Guilty Gear/Blazblue 13
10. Dead or Alive 0
11. One Must Fall 5
12. Darkstalkers 4
13. Pocket Fighter 4
14. Garou: Mark of the Wolves 3
15. IK+ 3
16. Fatal Fury 1
17. Body Blows 0
18. Last Blade/Samurai Showdown 2
19. Sango Fighter 5
20. Yie Ar Kung Fu 1
21. Super Smash Bros 5
22. Powerstone 1
23. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure 2

+1 for Soul Edge/Calibur, +1 for Guilty Gear/Blazblue, and +2 for Super Smash Bros.

Continuity?