I've had a win 8 laptop for about a year now. If I were coming strait from XP then I might think the bevy of advancement and shiny things to be a step forward, but up from Win7 (and even linux environments) my enthusiasm is tempered.
Metro is just an obnoxious sort of thing. I get that touch devices are a big thing, and that MS was hoping for a single, unified solution for both mobile and desktop worlds. I suppose I should even cut them a little slack for not getting it perfect on the first try, but... It is obvious they tossed the desktop experience into the back seat. Even in the little things like the messages that say "tap here to..." It's your DT OS and you couldn't even be inclusive enough of your user base to say "touch or click " instead?
And do I really need to remap all my default applications to keep the thing from leaping out of my desktop to give me some full screen app experience I don't really want? If I open a jpg it wants to app mode the image. With picture viewer I could then move about the folder looking at any other images, but the default behavior has me looking at the one image in app mode that I then have to go to an increased amount of trouble to close. I can't look at the other images, and the whole thing takes more time to launch and wind down all while offering me a less powerful experience.
If we lived in a world where tablets were generally powerful enough to be a primary device you docked at home to work on after you were done poking and swiping about, then I could see the hybrid approach being beneficial. But right now it tends to be an either or situation, and all they did was toss mobile interaction into people's faces and then dismiss the annoyance as something someone ought to just slide out of the way if they didn't like it.
I've also had a number of compatibility issues, but maybe that is just me.
The having to link it to an account feels weird to me.
On the whole I just don't like it. It offers me zero benefits, while making it more cumbersome, and less intuitive to do the same things I used to do. On the laptop I can generally forget about the differences since I tend to end up right where I was, so I have that going for me.
I will say I like my Win8 phone alight. But then I don't really need it to do anything special, which is good because it doesn't. It was cheap, super responsive, and the touch screen is flawless. That said, I don't wan't it on a tablet. Probably not even if they were cheaper and didn't weigh as much as a brick.
Post edited March 21, 2014 by gooberking