DazBoots: The ******** fist fights are the thing that made me throw this game out with the garbage, and give it a final rating of 2/10.
It's a crying shame, I was really enjoying my self up to this stupidity. Why-o-why did the dev's think that these fist fights would be a good idea? They must have been drunk at the time.
Cymbeline: I was having difficulty with the fistfights too (on a pc), until I fell upon the same technique as Epona's above. Just put your fingers on WAD, look at the middle of the screen and let your periferal vision do the work. You won't really be able to watch the fight, you can't read the letters, but if something flashes on the left, hit A,. On the right, hit D. On top, hit W. On the bottom, move your finger down and hit S.
The letters always flash in the same place. It is fairly easy once you get the trick of it. I don't like it since I can't watch the fight graphics as once I start doing that, I miss the letters flashing. But at least I can get past that section.
Now I find fist fights a breeze. Arm wrestling on the other hand..........
Yes I managed to win in the end, but what really gets me is the damage it does to the games immersion; for example...
You are this mighty witcher who has done such remarkable things and defeated all sorts of vicious creatures, killed army's of men and darn near done the impossible.
Now here comes a big fat half dead hung-over guard, who couldn't fight his way out of a paper bag. He floors the witcher like he was a little girl, then hangs him by the neck while the witchers mates stand about with their fingers up their bums.
Sorry, but that just does not work for me.