It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
procyoniv: better do it in a game than in real life.
Tbh, I think I would have gone on some kind of a killing spree in my school at some point if I wouldn't have had Quake 3 (which I wasn't even able to get legally 14 years ago) as a vent. The people I would have massacred would surely have deserved it but I'm still glad it didn't come to this.

So yeah, I truly think that virtual killing is reducing real life violence.
Although the common opinion in the mass media in my place is, that those games create real-life violence, all the studies trying to prove that failed miserably and all they achieved was the consensus, that frustrating games create violent behaviour (Flappy Bird anyone?), not games depictim virtual violence.
Post edited March 26, 2015 by Klumpen0815
avatar
jamotide: ...no line, art can do everything
Even for art there are limits. You can still not insult living persons, even if you mask it as art. So if you for example take a picture of your neighbour, render him into a shooter, kill him there virtually and put in on youtube, you'll get a lot of trouble.

Or if you play the hypothetical concentration camp manager and it's maybe so real that Jewish people feel offended - probably it will be forbidden (although I still think that there is actually noone existing wanting to play such thing and also being in the right mind).

And also the mentioned Pedophilia perks in RPGs. In some countries even cartoon and animated child pornography is out of question (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2005-03-04/canadian-arrested-for-importing-loli-porn-manga). It's surely debatable if it wouldn't be better to allow virtual pedophilia but at least currently art cannot do everything.
avatar
Klumpen0815: That just shows, that the scale of the weight of crimes in the legal system is another one than in big parts of the population. You may define your moral standards by your countries laws (which I doubt, there are always ones with which you'll disagree), but nobody else really does it in every case.
So you are telling me there are people who think rape is worse than murder? There are people who rather had their wifes, moms, sisters, daughtered been killed than raped? Do you realise that rape is kind of common? There is a good chance one of your relatives has been raped, would you rather have them be dead? I can't believe anyone except maybe honour killers really feel this way.

avatar
Klumpen0815: As I've written, not the line for forbidding something but for what is inacceptable for oneself, I'm sure there is something you'd feel a problem with, being able to and getting rewarded for kidnapping and raping a child, murdering it, raping it again, pissing on it, feeding it to your dogs and burning the rest on its mother's lawn maybe? If it's shown pretty realistic, I'm sure you'd feel some kind of wrongness when seeing it, telling me you wouldn't is hypocritical.
It is just a game, not real, why would it make me feel bad? Why do other murders ingame not make you feel bad? Because you are a hypocrite.
avatar
jamotide: ...no line, art can do everything
avatar
Trilarion: Even for art there are limits. You can still not insult living persons, even if you mask it as art. So if you for example take a picture of your neighbour, render him into a shooter, kill him there virtually and put in on youtube, you'll get a lot of trouble.

Or if you play the hypothetical concentration camp manager and it's maybe so real that Jewish people feel offended - probably it will be forbidden (although I still think that there is actually noone existing wanting to play such thing and also being in the right mind).

And also the mentioned Pedophilia perks in RPGs. In some countries even cartoon and animated child pornography is out of question (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2005-03-04/canadian-arrested-for-importing-loli-porn-manga). It's surely debatable if it wouldn't be better to allow virtual pedophilia but at least currently art cannot do everything.
Exactly.

avatar
jamotide: I can't believe anyone except maybe honour killers really feel this way.
That has to do with your horizon and your obvious lack of tolerance regarding other opinions.
As someone who survived quite a bit, I would prefer being murdered to being raped whether you accept it or not.

avatar
jamotide: Because you are a hypocrite.
Thanks for those words, I see you are a caring, emotional and kind person that knows me better than anyone else, way to go!
Post edited March 26, 2015 by Klumpen0815
avatar
Klumpen0815: That has to do with your horizon and your obvious lack of tolerance regarding other opinions.
As someone who survived quite a bit, I would prefer being murdered to being raped whether you accept it or not.
So you rather have your relatives be dead than raped? You realise just how common it is? There is a good chance one of em has been raped.

avatar
Klumpen0815: Thanks for those kind words, I see you are a caring, emotional and kind person, way to go!
Is this supposed to insult me?

avatar
Trilarion: Or if you play the hypothetical concentration camp manager and it's maybe so real that Jewish people feel offended - probably it will be forbidden (although I still think that there is actually noone existing wanting to play such thing and also being in the right mind).
Someone is always offended. Why is it different from genocide in Colonization?

avatar
Trilarion: but at least currently art cannot do everything.
I was asked where I want the line to be drawn. I think it should be able to do everything, I realise that often it can't.

avatar
Klumpen0815: Exactly.
lol, most of his reply is based on missing the context of my reply to your question. But yeah, exactly...
Post edited March 26, 2015 by jamotide
avatar
jamotide: So you are telling me there are people who think rape is worse than murder? There are people who rather had their wifes, moms, sisters, daughtered been killed than raped? Do you realise that rape is kind of common? There is a good chance one of your relatives has been raped, would you rather have them be dead? I can't believe anyone except maybe honour killers really feel this way.
While I agree murder is worse than rape I still agree with the others that people's opinions matter. If one has been through a shitty life, I'm sure inclination towards more shit is worse than death because in their perspective life has not much to offer. It's in all in the perspective of the person in question.
avatar
gamesfreak64: But i am not entirely helpless, i think i have a baseball bat lying around somewhere, a wooden one and i believe a metal one.
I got it long time ago, but i forgot what for, now i remember it was to prevent alien intelligence from experimenting with me.
avatar
awalterj: All you need to do now is add some cool mods to your baseball bat:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qFrKnqBJG6Q





avatar
gamesfreak64: If time should come to defend ourselves from such evil we can all meet en gang up to protect mother earth
maybe we will be able to pull of a Independence Day (nice movie, i have it on dvd)
avatar
awalterj: Vote for Falcon 4.0 on GOG so we can all practice!
http://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/falcon_40_original_not_allied_force

avatar
gamesfreak64: But if it has to be, i'd rather be laserbeamed to oblivion in startrek style , then slowly whackedof as they do now in real life.
avatar
awalterj: If having your head casually sawed off by inbred turds with rusty kitchen knives is the alternative then I'll take the lasers option, too!
> thats a nice promo for kickass 2 movie, i saw kickass movie and it was fun, not the maiming of people, but the way the good guys wasted the bad guys.

> i just voted for that falcon


if you could vote on this old classic:
http://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/gearhead_garage
it has 124 votes sofar any vote would be nice cause its a realy nice game

We the carfixers will be thankfull... its a good simple and fun carfixing game from the past
it seems there are more listed for the same game , perhaps gog can merge these with the biggest one which has 124 votes.
I feel this thread went off course a bit when somehow it turned to comparing rape and murder, because the thing is that hardly any of the popular videogames are about murder, and when a videogame actually is, it causes just as much controversy as a game about rape (see Postal and Hatred). Most videogames are about 'killing enemies', and killing enemies, as opposed to rape and torture is an internationally accepted solution for threats to the populace or your own life in RL, no matter how we as individuals may feel about it. Soldiers kill, policemen kill, assaulted people kill in self-defense, and it's all excused in the eyes of the law and society.

Most violent videogames make sure to tell you it's okay to kill because your opponents are 'bad' people who are threatening your life and the life of others, even those in which you are operating outside the law - e.g. you're a backstabbing assassin or a hitman for hire, but your targets are even more corrupt, and you're meant to feel like you're doing a 'service to society' in getting rid of them. (Imagine a game about assassinating iconic US presidents or members of the democratic opposition fighting for freedom, and how that would make the majority of players feel about themselves.) Add the themes of personal revenge - something almost any human can relate to, to a certain extent - and outrage about taboos - "that rapist/child molester/murderer deserves death!" -, and you have a perfect recipe for making people feel fine with all the killing in games precisely because it's not perceived as murder but as justice.

Rape on the other hand is something that's never excused nor glorified by society in RL, so I don't see what's hypocritical about people feeling strongly revolted to see it as a goal in videogames. If there's anything hypocritical at all, it would be people complaining about instrumentalized killing in videogames while accepting it as a solution to problems in real life (war, capital punishment etc.).
Post edited March 26, 2015 by Leroux
You're right, too many excuses to kill. We need less excuses in games to kill if killing is the point of the game.

When I play the Hitman games or Dishonored I try to imagine being the character I'm playing and that I chose that career because I enjoy it and because I excel at it (intrinsic value) as opposed to a service to society or revenge for someone else (instrumental value).
But it is exactly this kind of double standard that invites people to campaign for bans of killing games as well.
"We think killing is wrong, so videogames who allow you to do it should be banned. Wait whats that, you don't think so, but at the same time you think games that have rape should be banned? We agree, lets ban stuff!"
Post edited March 26, 2015 by jamotide
avatar
gamesfreak64: if you could vote on this old classic:
http://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/gearhead_garage
it has 124 votes sofar any vote would be nice cause its a realy nice game

We the carfixers will be thankfull... its a good simple and fun carfixing game from the past
it seems there are more listed for the same game , perhaps gog can merge these with the biggest one which has 124 votes.
I'm not into car games (except for P.O.D and Stunts/4D Sports Driving) and my knowledge of car mechanics/tuning is zero but Gearhead Garage looks like an original game that car enthusiasts can enjoy so I voted for it.
Pixels and data. They're just incredibly vivid products of imagination.
avatar
gamesfreak64: if you could vote on this old classic:
http://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/gearhead_garage
it has 124 votes sofar any vote would be nice cause its a realy nice game

We the carfixers will be thankfull... its a good simple and fun carfixing game from the past
it seems there are more listed for the same game , perhaps gog can merge these with the biggest one which has 124 votes.
avatar
awalterj: I'm not into car games (except for P.O.D and Stunts/4D Sports Driving) and my knowledge of car mechanics/tuning is zero but Gearhead Garage looks like an original game that car enthusiasts can enjoy so I voted for it.
thank you.... i dont like car games like driving aswell, and i am non technical, i dont know anything about cars, but i liked the demo so thats why i voted for it.
Thanks again for voting.
I have voted for many games , most of them i dont like or play, but if i can help some users, i am happy to vote on something.

avatar
Darvond: Pixels and data. They're just incredibly vivid products of imagination.
they are.

do you remember Yie Ar Kung-Fu ? i had it on tape later on c64 disc(retail)

also had IK plus
also on c64 and on AMIGA 500
i had that simple bruce lee game (cassette only )

pirates! and airborne ranger (pixels) but very good games and quite expensive in the old days (guilders)

69 guilders for pirates! and 59 guilders for airborneranger (51/4 discs for 1541 drive)
nice manuals, great games.

i also had Labyrint (yup from the movie)
Big Trouble in Litte China (pixels stuff)
sort of aliens game, rambo game and rambo 3 game (discs)
ah those good old pixels days, funny thing is that nowadays my eyes have to get used to all that pixels again, because the eyes are spoiled with nowadays super resoution graphics, so when playing some old games it takes time to make the eyes peep together to see the detail (or i play it in a small dox box making the pixels look better)
Post edited March 26, 2015 by gamesfreak64
avatar
gamesfreak64: do you remember ____?
Sorry, no memories of an era I was born long after. I was three months before the collapse of the USSR.
avatar
gamesfreak64: do you remember ____?
avatar
Darvond: Sorry, no memories of an era I was born long after. I was three months before the collapse of the USSR.
that collapse was in the nineties i guess?
i was 25 about then i guess,
yes the games i mentioned are very old i was like 14 or so when i got the c64.