Fever_Discordia: When you play a computer RPG do you decide what you're character's like and try to keep an internal logic and personality to their actions or do you do whatever gets you most XP and gold to power up as fast as possible and maximise your efficiency?
I was reading some tips for playing Geneforge and it was talking about which factions to join when and who to betray when to get the most training and upgrades possible and I thought, yeah, maybe, but I don't want to DO that because my guy wouldn't do that, it goes against what he has decided is right and wrong in this situation.
I suppose you could decide that your guy is a sneaky duplicitous guy as well for a middle way
So who picks a side and sticks to it, who backstabs but still thinks of their guy as a backstabby guy and to who does 'having a guy' not even occur and extracting the most of various metrics out of the game is like a mathematical problem to be solved?
Role-play all the way. I've never been a min/max kind of guy. It's just not for me. I like to get into my character who is often a reflection of my own self and act according to my own values and beliefs when I encounter various situations, dialog choices, etc.
The only time I kind of min/max is I will read up on character creation and try to create a character or characters that are well suited to what they are setting out to do. I guess even there though, it still falls back to role-play as the character(s) need to be a reflection of who I want them to be.
Playing with a role-play mindset is really fun to me. I want to be immersed in a world and story rather than focused on gaming the system. I guess it is possible to combine those things but I couldn't be bothered.