Jotamide: Sorry for the thread necro, but after how awful the HD releases on consoles turned out to be, it would be AMAZING to somehow people brought these games to the top of the wishlist.
I mean right now, SH 2 and SH 3 would be graphically superior to the so-called "HD collection" versions. After some tweaking of course.
It would be really unlikely for this to happen, but a man can dream.
Atropels: I couldn't agree more.
I was playing the "HD Collection" of Silent Hill the other day (Promotional copy) and It was just plain awful. I played the HD collection on my X360 and the originals on my PS2 (with a component cable, btw.) Of course I saw the difference from the original games to HD, but I preferred the old games by far.
The so called "HD" graphics have ruined a lot of the environment integrated in the game by removing a significant part of the texture details. I can't even begin to explain how much of the towns mystique and "charm" that have removed in the Collection, So I Hope this video will explain what I mean.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7DE9zNkB5A Furthermore the HD collection have actually removed small parts of the cutscenes in SH2
(if you have played the game, you know which I'm talking about) due to the PG-Ratings.
This alone is outrageous since it's some of most significant parts (storywise) of the game. If you buy and pay for the "remake" of the old games, but don't get the full experince, it's not a collection.
At very last the HD "Collection" offers new voice overs which isn't a big deal. If you haven't played the games before you may be able to get used to them, but if you're a old time fan, the new voices just doesn't fit into the SH universe.
Even though we'll be able to print cheese from our computers before SH comes on GOG, it would be amazing if it would happen, since it would provide an alternative other than the HD collection for people who haven't played the game or/and don't own a PS2.