I love Alone in the Dark, but it's old and not so scary any more. Blood is also one of my favourites, but it's really a shooter with a horror theme. Dead Space is pretty good, I played it on PC. Some people had problems with mouse lag, but I never had an issue. Condemned is pretty good too, and I would recommend F.E.A.R. (I was particularly fond of Perseus Mandate myself). Scratches was good, though I never finished it. Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth is good, but I need to finish it up (I would also suggest using the patch thing to increase your movement speed, otherwise you're ridiculously slow, to the point of it being nearly game-breaking at the end). The Thing was pretty good, I enjoyed it a lot. Of course, System Shock 2 is a huge one. The 7th Guest is pretty good too.
So, I would break it down to 3 like this:
Dead Space
Scratches
Blood
If you're willing to get into emulation, there's a fan translation of the first Clock Tower for the SNES out there.
EDIT: Fuuuuuuuuck, I spent to long typing this. Scratch Dead Space and replace with Alone in the Dark.
Post edited February 11, 2012 by doccarnby