It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
nmillar: The flavour text he received suggested he got an accurate result on both me and you ...
avatar
Vitek: How does it make him confirmed town?
Because the Flavor Cop is a pro-town role.

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Flavor_Cop
avatar
nmillar: Because the Flavor Cop is a pro-town role.

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Flavor_Cop
Jesters also tend not to be mafia, looking at game 3, mafia tends not to be able to discern people's names. I don't think "it's generally a town role" means a thing.
Well, I don't think we're going to get anywhere today; I suggest a nolynch, which will give us better odds tomorrow (one less suspect).
avatar
nmillar: Because the Flavor Cop is a pro-town role.

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Flavor_Cop
It's quite similar role to name cop and it can be mafia too. ;-)
I am quite concerned with fact that our roles doesn't imply anything at all about players so flavour cop is quite useless in this game. Dormouse was Cop, March Hare Godfather, White King Tracker, Tweedledum Mafia Roleblocker, etc.
avatar
nmillar: Because the Flavor Cop is a pro-town role.

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Flavor_Cop
avatar
Vitek: It's quite similar role to name cop and it can be mafia too. ;-)
I am quite concerned with fact that our roles doesn't imply anything at all about players so flavour cop is quite useless in this game. Dormouse was Cop, March Hare Godfather, White King Tracker, Tweedledum Mafia Roleblocker, etc.
So you suspect me because I don't have a powerful role?
No I don't, but it's what I was given.
Is a vanilla any more powerful?
Or a neighbour?
At least my role is proven.
The "I'd rather finish my tea" votecount

Orryyrro - 1 - Rodzaju
Rodzaju - 1 - Orryyrro
nolynch - 1 - nmillar
nmillar - 1 - Vitek

With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch. It's five days before sunset.
avatar
Rodzaju: So you suspect me because I don't have a powerful role?
No I don't, but it's what I was given.
Is a vanilla any more powerful?
Or a neighbour?
At least my role is proven.
No. I am concerned with going to nolynch to give you opportunity to investigate someone as nmillar suggested as it will probably tell us nothing.
avatar
Rodzaju: So you suspect me because I don't have a powerful role?
No I don't, but it's what I was given.
Is a vanilla any more powerful?
Or a neighbour?
At least my role is proven.
avatar
Vitek: No. I am concerned with going to nolynch to give you opportunity to investigate someone as nmillar suggested as it will probably tell us nothing.
Here at least, I am inclined to agree with you.
The ony person I can investigate is Orry.
He knew my role when he claimed.
Therefore he would be a fool to have lied about his name.
I do not have any info regarding his role, so I cannot help there.
We are at mylo, so we have to lynch correctly or nolynch.
However, unless some more info can come from somewhere, tomorrow will leave us in a worse position, of having to lynch correctly or lose.
WARNING: WALL OF TEXT AHEAD.

SLOW DOWN NOW TO AVOID COLLISION!!

For me, the key information we currently have is the order of the night kills:

The cop goes first, so no direct acusations.
Then the tracker, so we can’t tie a suspects’ visits to victims.
Then the doc, so no last minute saves.

With all the various roles that could be present & all the people still in the game on the relevant nights, this organised a sequence simply cannot have happened by accident.

This is where Vitek’s suspicion of me falls down.

Every night I have been busy.
Night 1 I investigated Vitek.
Night 2 I investigated Nmillar.
Depending who you believe, Night 3 I either investigated or killed Twilight & night 4 I either investigated or killed Quad.
So when was I able to get the information on who to kill?

I firmly believe that there is another investigative role out there, probably role cop.
This is the last mafia.

Despite the various random accusations I don’t see it being Vitek.
At the time you were ‘blocked’ the roleblocker was still around.
We also had tracker & doc.

If you were planning to claim a block regardless, there is WAY too much chance this would have been counter claimed by the person who was actually blocked.
Therefore I have to accept your claimed role.

That means that either Orry or Nmillar are lying about their role.

At this point, the only real case I can make against Nmillar is the connection to the screwdriver that killed Twilight. However, in his defense, he was in his room night 2.
To get all the kills right, investigations must have been made every night, so it is probably not him.

This leaves Orry, who has been conspicously trying to stay under the radar the whole game.
Orry, who the cop was declaring as suspicous right before she died.
Orry, the person to drop the hammer on Violator just after a logical connection was made between them.

For me, it now all stacks up with 1 conclusion.....
avatar
Vitek: No. I am concerned with going to nolynch to give you opportunity to investigate someone as nmillar suggested as it will probably tell us nothing.
You're missing the point. We have a 1 in 4 chance of identifying the correct mafia member. If we go for a no-lynch, we have a 1 in 3 chance tomorrow. I don't give a damn about Rodzaju's investigation as it probably won't help us, but we'll have a better chance of guessing tomorrow.
avatar
Vitek: No. I am concerned with going to nolynch to give you opportunity to investigate someone as nmillar suggested as it will probably tell us nothing.
avatar
nmillar: You're missing the point. We have a 1 in 4 chance of identifying the correct mafia member. If we go for a no-lynch, we have a 1 in 3 chance tomorrow. I don't give a damn about Rodzaju's investigation as it probably won't help us, but we'll have a better chance of guessing tomorrow.
Well, I have a theory that a nolynch might help prove.

unvote, vote nolynch

@Rod, it could simply be that whoever it was was simply very lucky with their kills.
avatar
Orryyrro: Well, I have a theory that a nolynch might help prove.

unvote, vote nolynch

@Rod, it could simply be that whoever it was was simply very lucky with their kills.
I don't believe, especially in a game like this, that anyone can be THAT lucky.

Everyone else is throwing cardson the table, and you're STILL making vague hints.
What is your theory?
If we do go to no-lynch, I would encourage everyone not to rush their vote tomorrow unless they're 100% sure; one mis-vote is all it would take as the last remaining mafia member could just jump on that for a quick mis-lynch.
avatar
nmillar: If we do go to no-lynch, I would encourage everyone not to rush their vote tomorrow unless they're 100% sure; one mis-vote is all it would take as the last remaining mafia member could just jump on that for a quick mis-lynch.
That's where I think Nolynch falls down.
Needing 3 votes for a lynch today means that there has to be at least some consensus, even if the scum jumps on the wagon.

That & I am as close to 100% as I think I will ever get in this game.
I've simply run out of alternative suspects...
avatar
Orryyrro: Well, I have a theory that a nolynch might help prove.

unvote, vote nolynch

@Rod, it could simply be that whoever it was was simply very lucky with their kills.
avatar
Rodzaju: I don't believe, especially in a game like this, that anyone can be THAT lucky.

Everyone else is throwing cardson the table, and you're STILL making vague hints.
What is your theory?
My theory rests upon who gets nightkilled tonight in the event of a no-lynch, therefor revealing my thoughts would ruin it entirely.