orcishgamer: I'm genuinely curious what kind of "support" you give pirates by downloading a crack? Do you give them money? Make the famous? I think you're overreacting a bit. There's no difference between MM getting an exe crack or a full game crack. He already supported the devs (support which apparently was undeserved) and that's that.
cjrgreen: Pirates exist just because people download their ill-gotten goods. Even if their junk is "free", their sites get advertising revenue when you use them; that's a significant amount of income for them right there.
Every time you download from a pirate, that is a sale of no benefit to the copyright holder.
It cheapens and shortens the market for the legitimate game. It takes money out of the pockets of everybody who could have profited from that sale, or the subsequent sales that your freeloading off of pirates cheapened.
The part of this story where freeloading occurred is when someone sold a non-working copy of a game to the OP. Seriously, in what world do you live where people get payed jack shit for anything but clickthroughs on ads? Impressions count for shit (and generally pay nothing, or so close to nothing that a 10,000 of em wouldn't even get you a shiny dime), it's laughable to say the OP would be contributing anything financially to them (as if the crackers do it for financial gain, they aren't the ones running the trackers, hint hint).
The sale was as beneficial to the copyright holder as any other sale, they got the exact amount asked for said product (and failed to deliver a working product I might add), if some how your version of events is true, well who do the copyright holders have to blame but themselves?
Crackers exist because it's a challenge they don't see a dime from anyone who hosts their stuff, sites that aggregate free media do it for various reasons some financial and some for philosophical reasons. Regardless, getting a working copy of the game from them costs the copyright holders far less than support (supposing they're even willing to provide it) to fix the OP's problem, by orders of magnitude, in fact.
MM would be taking net nothing from the developers and frankly at this point it's more than they deserve.