Since Alone in the Dark was one of these Atari releases, maybe "What game made you dream of the stars? " refers to Shadow of the Comet, which is another HP.Lovecraft inspired game by the same company that made Alone in the Dark...

They made AITD, Shadow and Prisoner of Ice while owning the rights to do "Call of Cthulhu" video games.

What game made you dream of the stars?
- Galactic Civilizations

What game made you ride with the outlaws?
- Desperados: Wanted Dead or Alive

What game made you fear your past?
- Quake?

What game made you go to the underground?
- Doom?

What game made you feel like a hero?
- Forgotten Realms: Demon Stone

OOoooo Demon Stone would be wonderful! the fact that atari is selling it for download @ $9.99 makes me think its a good contender....

No, they just published some re-releases. All id games are now owned by Bethesda, who is not a GOG partner yet. I hope they will be someday though.

Well, [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Area_51_(1995_video_game)]Area 51[/url] (the 1996 PC title) is an Atari release (according to MobyGames, anyway), so it wouldn't surprise me if that was the case, maybe for the STARS one (because not only is it an alien invasion, but it is also the name of your team, even if it was slightly misspelled, STAAR).

Yeah, I will fully admit to being way off on F.E.A.R. and Homeworld, mainly because with the former I forgot it wasn't Atari, and with the latter, I thought that Atari/Infogrames helped out with that one when they didn't.

BJ

What game made you dream of the stars?
- Some old Star Wars or Star Trek game?

What game made you ride with the outlaws?
- Desperados: Wanted Dead or Alive [2]
Please be it, I love this game :D

What game made you fear your past?
- Bioforge?

What game made you go to the underground?
- Ultima Underworld?

What game made you feel like a hero?
- A lot :D Demon Stone would be cool. Pool of Radiance is missing in the D&D collection too :]

if we dont get rollercoaster tycoon this time im gonna be sad

What game made you dream of the stars?
Imperium Galactica

What game made you ride with the outlaws?
Desperados: Wanted Dead or Alive

What game made you fear your past?
Indigo Prophecy

What game made you go to the underground?
Dungeons & Dragons: Dragonshard

What game made you feel like a hero?
Forgotten Realms: Demon Stone

Sounds like a winner.

If Indigo Prophecy is the European version I will buy it. I'll probably get Dragonshard.

Is it just me or are the coming release boxes blurred? One of them looks familiar....I could almost swear one of them looks like the Homeworld box.

Unlikely. Homeworld's Sierra, meaning Activision, not Atari.

E.T.

I think some people are guessing it the wrong way.

The question reflects the title of the games, and not necessary the content.

Both
What game made monsters afraid of you?
What game made you afraid of dark?

represent the title.

Yeah, I thought it was all rather obvious, myself. There have only been a few people who connected "made you go to the Underground" with Ultima Underworld? Really???


-Khalaq

How does "monsters afraid of you" represent the word Witcher? It represents the content in that clue, not the title of the game. Unless I am mistaking your meaning.