ceeker: I was hanging out for this one for ages after first hearing about it, because it was one of those ideas that sprung into my head years ago - "Hey, wouldn't a James Bond RPG be cool?"
Saw the shitty reviews and bought it on release anyway. It did have a few problems, but by and large it was an enjoyable experience that I wanted to keep coming back to, even before the patch. Still don't really understand the negative feedback it received. Might even replay it at some point.
lowyhong: From what I understand of hearsay, it's because people don't know what to expect from the game. Those who treat it as a shooter seem to be especially disappointed because "omfg why cant i hit anything this game suxxxx".
Oh I don't "
love it" love it, but I don't hate it either. My problems with the game lie elsewhere and certainly not with the combat of the game, which I think is absolutely fine. It has its moments and I quite enjoyed it when I wasn't tearing my hair out at certain points. I'll probably give it a 7, though it could have been an 8-game, because I really, really hated the conversation wheel (and the ambiguity of the choices). It's also a game I don't mind going a 2nd playthrough too - and I don't say that for many games these days.
I'm probably the same really. I'd give it a 7.5, and a little more spit and polish would easily have boosted that up to an 8.
I didn't like the conversation wheel either (being more a fan of the old school "pick your sentence from a list" approach), but I liked how they were successful at making the conversations flow in a relatively natural way due to the timer and simple choices, which I felt gave them a more cinematic feel. I'm not sure it's possible to reconcile those two things, so I'm still divided on it.
My irritations were primarily technical in nature - In one example, I got told I killed the US marines in Moscow, when I did no such thing. I can forgive one or two of those, but there were enough such goings on that I felt it detracted from the experience as a whole. The combat is pretty much fine, the odd AI problem excluded. Oh, and the hacking minigame sucks. Once you get the hang of it, it's not impossible, but it never ceases to be a pain in the arse.
Definitely didn't understand the complaints about the graphics. They seemed to look up-to-date to me.