Posted February 07, 2009
Blarg: Example: My brother goes to Asia a lot. He works like hell but doesn't really know people there well enough to hang out with them every darn night, especially since they all smoke and drink like hell over there and he does neither. So even though he's very social, he faces some boring nights alone after his ridiculously long days. He might like a computer game. But is trying one out worth the chance of losing a disk drive, or any other kind of problem, on his computer? Not by a very long shot indeed.
You guys may be willing to take your computer use casually and roll lots of dice and recommend others do too, but that's the more ideological position by far. Some people just need to rely on their computers.
Ascribing every problem with DRM to someone's "system instability" is not just really reaching, it's misdirecting. Since I don't know you guys, I won't say purposefully. But I will say, for my brother, me, and countless others, it's being done irresponsibly.
You guys may be willing to take your computer use casually and roll lots of dice and recommend others do too, but that's the more ideological position by far. Some people just need to rely on their computers.
Ascribing every problem with DRM to someone's "system instability" is not just really reaching, it's misdirecting. Since I don't know you guys, I won't say purposefully. But I will say, for my brother, me, and countless others, it's being done irresponsibly.
Yes there's a risk with games that include DRM but, to quote police squad "You take a chance getting up in the morning, crossing the street or sticking your face into a fan". The odds of a DRMed game destroying an optical drive or otherwise causing hardware damage is very probably less than a plane crashing on you while you're in the bath.
You can't just assume that a problem is related to DRM when it's an extremely small element of a very large and complex system where every part must interact in harmony in order to get anything done. Sure DRM can ruin this harmony and no doubt does sometimes but then every single other element can have the same problems.
I've been doing IT in one form or another for decades and I know from LONG experience that very few people really how to use a computer properly and fewer still know how to troubleshoot properly. People hear "DRM broke my computer", see the problem they have bears a superficial similarity to the described one, see the game has the same DRM scheme and they therefore conclude that DRM caused it which is specious reasoning at best.
I rely on my computer for practically everything, entertainment, uni work and contact with the woman I love so it's pretty damned important to me. Risk management is a fairly subjective thing but if you were to build a risk table of probability of damage times magnitude of damage, DRM would be on the lower half of the table because the chances of occuring with serious hardware damage are so extremely small.
Sure there's SHITLOADS of potential for privacy damage but thats a different argument
Post edited February 07, 2009 by Aliasalpha